2 added 140 characters in body
source | link

Do you think this would help ease the conflict over comments?

Hard to tell.

If the core problem is the "number of comments" - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is that the "wrong kind of comments" are being posted (ie, random, parenthetical asides) - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is that people should be using Chat rather than Comments for much of what they are saying - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is the uneven distribution of comments - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is short, single-line text - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is comment quality - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is the amount of real estate taken up by comments - then hiding many of them seems like it would help.

If the core problem is comments distracting readers from the content of answers - then hiding many of them seems like it would help.

Do you think this would help ease the conflict over comments?

Hard to tell.

If the core problem is the "number of comments" - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is that the "wrong kind of comments" are being posted (ie, random, parenthetical asides) - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is that people should be using Chat rather than Comments for much of what they are saying - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is the uneven distribution of comments - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is short, single-line text - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is comment quality - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is the amount of real estate taken up by comments - then hiding many of them seems like it would help.

Do you think this would help ease the conflict over comments?

Hard to tell.

If the core problem is the "number of comments" - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is that the "wrong kind of comments" are being posted (ie, random, parenthetical asides) - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is that people should be using Chat rather than Comments for much of what they are saying - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is the uneven distribution of comments - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is short, single-line text - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is comment quality - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is the amount of real estate taken up by comments - then hiding many of them seems like it would help.

If the core problem is comments distracting readers from the content of answers - then hiding many of them seems like it would help.

1
source | link

Do you think this would help ease the conflict over comments?

Hard to tell.

If the core problem is the "number of comments" - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is that the "wrong kind of comments" are being posted (ie, random, parenthetical asides) - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is that people should be using Chat rather than Comments for much of what they are saying - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is the uneven distribution of comments - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is short, single-line text - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is comment quality - then hiding many of them probably won't help.

If the core problem is the amount of real estate taken up by comments - then hiding many of them seems like it would help.