18

Most (if not all) of the answers so far have been in direct relationship to the IT field - however, the title of this site is "The Workplace", not "The IT Workplace".

Are non-IT related questions on-topic?

Whatever this decision is should be encoded in the FAQ, since that way we have it documented.

  • Better now. I've removed my obsolete comments... – ChrisF Apr 10 '12 at 22:11
  • I've created the software-industry tag (for lack of a better label) to tag my (one) question that was actually domain specific – Rarity Apr 10 '12 at 22:24
33

I have been deliberately answering questions in a domain-neutral way, so far as is possible, so as you can probably tell, I think:

Yes.

It may be the case that many of the members of the private beta are in fact involved in IT - there's a heavy bias as a result of the size of the trilogy. That being said, there is no reason to restrict ourselves to the IT workplace and comparing/contrasting with other industries will provide better perspective.

  • 2
    Agreed. I would actually encourage suggested edits that remove industry-specific titles and tags, unless the question/dilema being posed is somehow specific to the industry in question - which I imagine will be unusual. – jefflunt Apr 10 '12 at 22:56
  • 1
    I strongly support this, and I've been asking questions that are either not field specific or that came up in the course of my business education. :D This site has the potential to be valuable well beyond the IT Field; I would hope we endeavor to reach that broader audience. – Aarthi Apr 11 '12 at 13:12
17

I would hope and expect that non IT questions are on topic, otherwise this site would be a subset of Programmers.

I would also expect most questions in the private beta (and indeed the early public beta) to be IT related simply because of the existing audience.

Once the site hits public beta it's up to all of us to publicise the site to our non-IT friends and acquaintances so that the user base can be broadened.

4

Very important question.

Just because of the demographics of the first users here, we're inevitably going to skew towards IT-related questions, but I think we should make a concerted effort to pull back in the other direction, as ninefingers says:

deliberately answering questions in a domain-neutral way, so far as is possible

Otherwise we might just as well migrate all of the closed Programmers questions here...

0

It appears to me that lots of job related questions on Programmers are getting closed as "off topic" so I do not believe that this site will be a subset of Programmers. Once it gets out of the private beta, I predict a number of other sites will put their own job related questions on the off-topic list and migrate them here.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .