1

In this question I have asked several questions in the comments, which are to a degree rhetorical - they could be considered answers in themselves if the words were rearranged, but the OP doesn't specify whether they are already doing those things so I felt it better to ask for clarification. They are not necessarily good quality answers, because the OP could reply to them "I'm already doing that and it hasn't helped".

Where an answer "Try doing X" could be phrased as a question "Have you tried X?" is it always better to make it a comment to ask the OP to specify in the question whether they have done these things?

  • 1
    It is important to ask for clarification up to some degree (have you tried...?), but realistically we can't keep asking for clarification forever. At some point answerers have to content with what the question explains and make some assumptions/premises; this is when "Try doing X" could be a valid phrasing, for which OP can clarify in the answer he/she has already done that so the answerer can adapt – DarkCygnus Jun 1 '18 at 15:44
7

Adding half-answers to comments can often lead to comments being turned into discussions, which isn't really what comments are there for. And comments containing answers have a habit of being deleted.

See Comments

You should submit a comment if you want to:

  • Request clarification from the author;
  • Leave constructive criticism that guides the author in improving the post;
  • Add relevant but minor or transient information to a post (e.g. a link to a related question, or an alert to the author that the question has been updated).

Generally speaking, comments under questions should be mainly be there for clarification purposes, and once your clarification has been addressed, it's only polite to delete the comment (it just helps keep things tidy and stops you from looking like you've asked for a clarification for something that's already in the question....)

5

Personally, I don't think answers are appropriate in this context. In preparation of writing an answer, it seems like a good idea in most cases to ask some questions in the comments to validate some assumptions and prepare a basis for your answer. Without the clarification, the answer runs the risk of missing the mark. This is especially true since 'try doing X' should always be 'try doing X because reason Y'.

In fact, such questions should prompt the OP to edit their question and add the answers to the questions asked in the comments, so that the back-and-forth comments can then be cleaned up.

  • 2
    This. When a question doesn't give context, it's best to ask for it in comments (and then either edit the question once they're answered, or suggest the OP edit the answers in). Besides helping you frame up your OWN answer, this will be a benefit to anyone else answering or commenting on the question - it's best to have this info front and center in the original question, versus the worst-case of posting an answer and having the OP comment that they've already tried it. – dwizum May 31 '18 at 20:25

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .