Questions tagged [comments]
The comments tag has no usage guidance.
71
questions
1
vote
1answer
97 views
Why was my comment deleted, but not the replies to it?
I posted a highly upvoted comment which was not asking for clarification on the question, so I understand why it was deleted. But why weren't the replies to my comment deleted also?
This is not the ...
-3
votes
1answer
162 views
Why are nasty comments allowed [closed]
I been here for more than a year now and dont say much but here is what I notice
I seen a few people run off and this bothered me for a while now when people can comment like this and flagging it ...
3
votes
3answers
274 views
Inconsistent comment moderation appears capricious
So I had a long comment thread form under one of my trademarked "Harsh Truth" answers here:
How can I reply to coworkers who accuse me of automating people out of work?
And I notice one comment I ...
-4
votes
1answer
99 views
Did my comment get deleted?
In addition to a well received answer on this thread, I originally made a comment underneath the question suggesting to the OP that he should avoid stating his bad financial situation ("broke" - his ...
1
vote
3answers
118 views
“As a manager myself…” Do appeals to identity improve or diminish answers?
I frequently see an appeal to identity in answers and comments - especially "As a manager myself..." - including my own. I've had a variety of reactions ranging from seeing the appeal as way of ...
-5
votes
1answer
101 views
Where did the comments go?
There were a bunch of comments on Should my manager be aware of private LinkedIn approaches I receive? How to politely have this happen?. A seemingly random bunch of them were deleted. There is no "...
4
votes
1answer
224 views
What determines whether comments are deleted or moved to chat?
As is all to common here, we have had yet another Meta question asking why comments were removed from a post. The answer to this is pretty clear, and I'm not at all questioning their removal.
One ...
-9
votes
4answers
356 views
Some mod is completely out of control on this board
Dangerous workplace travelling
This question had multiple comments which identified the area the OP was talking about, and had discussions about the relative safety of the US vs. other nations of the ...
4
votes
1answer
61 views
Missing comment notifications?
Has anyone else been having missing notifications? I posted an answer on a Meta thread and had two users comment on it, but I never received any notification for the comments. Has anyone else been ...
2
votes
2answers
53 views
Comments moved to chat, link is 404
I wanted to read the comments of this answer. One of them, from a mod, says:
Comments are not for extended discussion; this conversation has been moved to chat
But the link points to 404 Not Found ...
-5
votes
3answers
144 views
Was my comment not useful?
Edit: Rather than ask why my comment was deleted, I’d rather ask, was it not useful?
I understand moderator fatigue is real, and comments are noisy — especially in Workplace — but, for a while, my ...
1
vote
1answer
44 views
Locating comments moved to chat
So I add a comment to a question and I can track the question I commented on by digging into my profile and looking at my history.
But it turns out that this was a contentious question and a large ...
-1
votes
4answers
165 views
Is using comments to point out flaws in answers frowned upon here?
As a Stack Overflow user who wanders over to Workplace sometimes via the Hot Network Questions section, I'm not sure I understand the commenting norms here, and would like to present a case study.
I ...
2
votes
0answers
43 views
Update example comment in Tour
I know we've been working a lot lately on trying to get comments more in line with the guidelines, in particular keeping them to concrete requests for clarification and limiting the amount of ...
2
votes
4answers
207 views
Recent increase in comment deletion?
What is going on with the up tick of deleting comments? To be specific, I am not talking about comments that should be deleted such as:
Great answer +1
What a dumb question
Go fly a kite, I cannot ...
2
votes
1answer
58 views
Why can I not comment? [duplicate]
I was trying to add a comment to this question, but found only "suggest improvements" and "show all comments" links; none for adding new comments.
This appears to be a new thing. I'm not 100% sure, ...
2
votes
1answer
99 views
I don't understand what is wrong in my question and why the comments are given opinion based and rude?
I have a question about my The Workplace Stack Exchange post: How to deal with the persons whose actions delays in taking decision?
As soon as I posted this question, I started receiving down votes ...
-2
votes
3answers
167 views
Why was this comment – which suggested an improvement to my answer – deleted?
This comment was deleted/moved to chat, yet it seems to me that this particular comments meets the requirement for posting comments: it constructively suggested an improvement to the answer, ...
2
votes
1answer
33 views
Another question about the comments; reminders of the “Be Nice” policy
General question here.
If we see nastiness in the comments section, should we drop in a reminder of the "be nice" policy (not directed to a particular user) or just flag for a mod without comment?
36
votes
10answers
1k views
Experiment concluded: a comment by any other name
This experiment has ended; you can view the report here.
Last year, Robert Cartaino relayed this one weird trick to fix comments:
I also flag dozens-to-hundreds of posts daily simply to remove ...
3
votes
3answers
166 views
“Poaching” for other sites?
I've noticed a few times, users poaching for other stacks and suggesting an already answered, and up-voted question should be somewhere else.
What (if anything) should we do about this?
Example: ...
1
vote
2answers
62 views
Is answering a question with a question always a comment?
In this question I have asked several questions in the comments, which are to a degree rhetorical - they could be considered answers in themselves if the words were rearranged, but the OP doesn't ...
-4
votes
3answers
127 views
Comments being deleted [duplicate]
I've noticed some comments of mine have been deleted. In this question the comments were, from memory
a comment that marking the question as a duplicate did not make sense
a comment that RichardU's ...
5
votes
1answer
50 views
Which is more useful to the mods, Flagging comments, or the Q or A they are in? [duplicate]
There have been recent events where a good deal of unhelpful comments have hit some Questions and Answers. In most cases they all come in a series of them.
Would it be more useful to the mods for us ...
1
vote
2answers
65 views
Deletions of clarifying comments from the OP
A number of clarifying comments from the OP were unceremoniously deleted from "Am I being asked to lie in my job?" (they were attached to the top answer, I believe).
While I understand the SE-wide ...
1
vote
1answer
36 views
Can you help me read the last comment on this deleted question?
The question was deleted before I had a chance to read the last comment. Since I visit this site only via the app, I have no saved URL from the browser history to give you. Thanks.
3
votes
1answer
229 views
Comments are not for extended discussion - long-term solution discussion
Is seems like the mods here might be getting a bit frustrated with all the extended discussion going on in the comments. Is this accurate?
This post is mostly going by the assumption that this is a ...
-3
votes
1answer
113 views
Can we remove the suggestion to leave a comment on down voting
We do not have a problem with drive by downvoting... we have a problem with people wanting to attack those who try to post a helpful answer being attacked for their efforts in the comments. And then ...
11
votes
3answers
378 views
Why was my comment on this answer deleted?
What I did
I left a comment on this answer explaining that I downvoted because of the recommendation for cussing out your superior. It also contained a speculation about what a preceding comment was ...
4
votes
1answer
92 views
How to report multiple obsolete comments?
This initial version of this question (Team members ignore their work and are not being held responsible. How can I restore order?) received a lot of comments stating that it read like a rant, and ...
3
votes
2answers
230 views
What is the criteria to get rude or un-necessary comment removed?
First and foremost I enjoy this site. I like helping others where I can, and I know I can have strong opinions, but with no malice towards anyone and in the spirit of helping others.
Having said ...
5
votes
4answers
159 views
If I can see comments are getting out of hand, what can/should I do?
I know The Workplace gets a lot of comments. And often, they get quite hot. It's not unusual for person A to ask a question, person B, C, and D to answer, and then E and F get into an extended ...
-14
votes
5answers
489 views
I despise “The Workplace” thanks to the admins who move comments to chat
I really despise the workplace due to the amount of comments moved to chat even when the comments are on topic. This of all the SE sites is probably the most notorious for moving very relevant ...
-7
votes
1answer
62 views
To cut down on comment chatter, remove support for “@” except to invite someone to comment
The most useful comments are aimed at the OP. Some of them should persist long after talk on the answer has died down. Notifications tend to suck people in who have run out of useful things to say to ...
19
votes
1answer
329 views
Comment flagging - please try to use an appropriate flag type
Until recently, comment flag type did not matter very much and as moderators we basically processed them regardless of type.
As a reminder when flagging there are the following options:
From here:
...
0
votes
1answer
111 views
Deletion of comments on bad answer
Recently, an "answer" that was wrong in several ways was posted and several people commented on how wrong it was. Currently after twenty downvotes, the person who posted it and someone else are ...
4
votes
3answers
177 views
Request for data: What has been removed here as rude/abusive?
The Workplace has had a lot of discussions/arguments about what is or isn't rude. This came up most recently in chat, but it's at the core of a bunch of past meta questions too. It was also ...
21
votes
1answer
393 views
Could we be less aggressive about moving comments to chat?
Popular questions tend to attract a ton of comments.
Example
Questions on this site tend to attract more comments than on other sites because:
the topics are circumstance-specific and require lots ...
7
votes
2answers
732 views
What does IANAL mean?
Been binge reading on The Workplace questions and some people comment the word IANAL and then append their comment. What does that mean?
-1
votes
2answers
82 views
Are questions and comments involving management theory appropriate?
Many questions on this exchange address situations in the workplace. Workplace experience successfully handling tough situations at work qualifies a person as expert. This form of expertise seems ...
5
votes
1answer
64 views
Is it possible for a Moderator to edit multiple user comments for privacy reasons?
A user asked this question and then realized they had used their real name and wanted to change that. They were instructed how to change their user name here but several of the comments seem to still ...
2
votes
1answer
50 views
Why can't I delete a comment on a Question which is on hold?
I like to delete comments after a few days, so that I don't contribute to our
"Comments Problem".
But I can't delete any comment when the associated question is On Hold or locked. Thus, I end up ...
2
votes
1answer
61 views
I think some of my comments were removed - can I find out?
I seem to remember commenting on a question a day or two ago, but didn't see that comment when I visited it again today. I remember atleast one other time this happened in the past.
Given what I ...
-3
votes
3answers
68 views
Can we reward upvotes for comments?
Users have the ability to upvote comments, as well as answers.
Upvotes for answers give an increase to reputation. Upvotes for comments give you nothing.
Can we give rep changes for comment votes?
5
votes
1answer
199 views
Shame on us! We must treat new users better!
https://workplace.stackexchange.com/users/40274/jack-d-ripper
This user was not attempting to ask bad questions or question on how to exploit or get around the system. He was asking questions about ...
3
votes
1answer
35 views
Unable to tag users in reply to comments
For this question here, How can international students with weak work experience overcome logistical difficulties in seeking work in the United States? , I am unable to tag users as I want to reply to ...
18
votes
3answers
377 views
What is wrong with comments?
Anytime a question or answer seems to have more than 5 comments, they get axed by the "comment" police. I notice one moderator seems to do this a lot more than they others.
My question is this: ...
4
votes
1answer
197 views
Why was this comment on the handshake question deleted?
In the question How does one politely decline a handshake due to religious reasons? , I wrote the comment
This question should be migrated to Islam.SE
It has been deleted.
Why was this deleted?
7
votes
2answers
236 views
Why was my comment deleted?
On this question, Does HR asking for salary slips and earliest joining date mean I have got the job?, I had a rather late realization that the OP is likely to be from India. I hadn't noticed his name ...
12
votes
1answer
326 views
Reason for deleting comments?
Several days ago (perhaps week before last?), I posted a comment on this answer:
https://workplace.stackexchange.com/a/36407/16724
As closely as I can recall, my comment was:
This answer is the ...
